Conference

Contacts & Sponsorship

World of Shipping Portugal

An International Research Conference on Maritime Affairs

21 - 22 November 2019, Carcavelos, Portugal

Full Conceptual Paper Review Form

Please always keep a record of your evaluation until we confirm in writing that your review has been safely received!

If we do not provide any feedback within the 48 hours timeframe, please send an email to Ana Casaca.

Please note that all fields with ( * ) must be completed.

* Name of Reviewer:

* Email:

* Title of Paper:

* Code of Paper:

* 1. Please rate the paper according to the following Evaluation Criteria

Evaluation Criteria	Strongly Disagree	Disagree	Slightly Disagree	Slightly Agree	Agree	Strongly Agree
Evaluation Criteria	(1)	(2)	(3)	(4)	(5)	(6)
* Relevance of the Paper relatively to the Call for Papers

* Appropriateness of the Paper's Title relatively to its content

* Clarity and Structure of the Paper

* Problem Formulation

* Consistency of the Methodology: Research Design

* Consistency of the Methodology: Logical development of concept/theory

* Consistency of the Methodology: Use of evidence to support position

* Paper's Originality, Innovativeness and Value

* Contribution of the Paper to the Body of Literature

* Use of Sources / References

* Quality of Writing

* Paper Length

* Quality of the Overall Paper

* 2. Additional Comments

* 2.1. Comments to Authors

Please provide further constructive comments on the paper’s limitations/weaknesses. Comments should be as complete and detailed as possible and contain clear opinions about recommendations on how this paper can be improved. Specific comments that cite manuscript sections, pages, paragraphs, or lines are exceptionally useful.

* 2.2. Comments to the Organising Committee

* 3. Would you award this Paper with the title of “Conference Best Paper”?

Yes

* 4. Final Decision

Reject

Thank you for your cooperation!

Top of the page

Media Partner

Updated @ 30 June 2019